Redrafting the Rookies: 2024 vs 2025 vs 2026 Dynasty Mock Draft I CouchScouts Podcast Ep. 136

What happens when you throw the 2024, 2025, and 2026 rookie classes into one dynasty Superflex draft? The 2024 class still controls the top of the board, but Jeremiah Love, Ashton Jeanty, Carnell Tate, and other young players make the gap between classes much more interesting once you get past the elite dynasty assets.

This exercise wasn’t about rookie hype. It was about answering one question: If we were drafting these players today, knowing what we know now, who would we actually want to build a dynasty roster around?

Episode Timestamps

• 2:22 – Round 1 begins: Drake Maye, Jayden Daniels and Brock Bowers lead the board

• 7:36 – Jeremiah Love vs. Ashton Jeanty: Which young RB belongs higher?

• 12:01 – Bucky Irving, Jaxson Dart, Tetairoa McMillan and Omarion Hampton

• 24:37 – Round 2 begins: Tyler Warren, Bo Nix and Carnell Tate

• 29:37 – Travis Hunter sparks the biggest debate before the late-round values emerge

2024 Still Owns the Top of the Dynasty Board

The first five selections told the story quickly:

1.01 Drake Maye1.02 Jayden Daniels1.03 Brock Bowers1.04 Caleb Williams1.05 Malik Nabers

Maye earned the 1.01 because he offers the combination dynasty managers want in Superflex formats: size, arm talent, rushing ability and long-term quarterback upside. Daniels brings even more explosiveness as a runner, but his durability creates a little more uncertainty.

Bowers at 1.03 shows just how valuable an elite young tight end can be in a premium format. His ability as a route runner, receiver and yards-after-catch weapon gives him a positional advantage few players can match.

Then you still have Williams and Nabers — two players with the talent to remain foundational dynasty pieces for years.

The takeaway is simple: the 2024 class has already produced an elite tier that the younger classes are still trying to reach.

Jeremiah Love vs. Ashton Jeanty Is Already a Real Debate

The first 2026 player came off the board at 1.06 with Jeremiah Love, immediately followed by Ashton Jeanty at 1.07.

Love received the slight edge because of his explosiveness and receiving upside. His third-down skill set gives him a path to becoming the type of running back who can score fantasy points even when the rushing production isn’t there.

Jeanty may be the more natural runner between the tackles. His contact balance, tackle-breaking ability and fit in the offense still give him elite dynasty upside.

There isn't a massive gap between these two. They belong in the same tier, and roster construction could easily determine which one a dynasty manager prefers.

Bucky Irving Has Earned His Dynasty Value

Bucky Irving at 1.08 might have looked aggressive a year ago. It doesn’t anymore.

The film evaluation coming out of college showed an elusive, explosive runner who could contribute on all three downs. He has since proven that skill set translates.

That matters when evaluating young players. Draft capital and prospect profiles are important, but eventually NFL film has to take over. Irving has shown he can create yards, handle significant volume and stay involved as a receiver.

That makes him more than a former rookie sleeper. He has become a legitimate dynasty cornerstone at running back.

The rest of Round 1 included:

1.09 Jaxson Dart1.10 Tetairoa McMillan1.11 Omarion Hampton1.12 Colston Loveland

Dart’s rushing willingness gives him legitimate fantasy upside at quarterback, while Hampton remains one of the most physically impressive young running backs in football. Loveland also has a path toward becoming a long-term difference-maker at a scarce fantasy position.

Carnell Tate Could Be the 2026 Receiver to Bet On

One of the most interesting selections came at 2.03 with Carnell Tate.

Tate’s college production profile may not look like the traditional elite wide receiver prospect, but the film tells a more complete story.

He can win at all three levels. His routes are smooth and efficient, he can threaten defenses vertically, and there is very little wasted movement in his game. The biggest question is how much he can consistently create after the catch.

Still, the combination of route-running ability, draft investment and opportunity gives Tate a chance to become significantly more productive in the NFL than he was in college.

For dynasty managers who prioritize film over box-score scouting, Tate is exactly the type of player worth targeting.

Travis Hunter Is the Ultimate Risk-Reward Dynasty Asset

The most aggressive selection of the draft was probably Travis Hunter at 2.04.

The talent isn't the concern. Hunter showed elite ability as a receiver in college and flashed that upside before his rookie season was interrupted.

The issue is his role.

If Hunter receives consistent offensive opportunities, his ceiling remains enormous. If his defensive responsibilities significantly limit his receiver snaps, it becomes difficult to justify valuing him alongside players with more secure fantasy roles.

That makes Hunter one of the most fascinating dynasty assets in football: the upside remains elite, but the range of outcomes is much wider than it is for most players in this part of the draft.

Final Dynasty Takeaway

After two rounds, the final class breakdown was:

2024: 10 players2025: 11 players2026: 3 players

That doesn’t necessarily mean the 2026 class is significantly weaker. Those players simply haven't had the same opportunity to prove themselves at the NFL level.

The bigger takeaway is how deep the young talent pool has become. Drake Maye, Jayden Daniels and Brock Bowers may sit at the top today, but players like Jeremiah Love, Ashton Jeanty, Carnell Tate and Jordyn Tyson have a chance to climb quickly.

For dynasty managers, don't scout the class label. Scout the player. Film, NFL role, positional value and long-term opportunity matter far more than whether a prospect entered the league in 2024, 2025 or 2026.

Want to see the film yourself? Join the CouchScouts to unlock these prospects' Scouting Profiles and access our database of All-22 cutups. Want to join the conversation? Join our free Discord to engage with a community of 250+ Dynasty Fantasy Football enthusiasts and get real-time advice.