MENTAL GAME
Simpson operates primarily as a half-field reader and rarely works through full-field progressions. While he shows some competence with pre-snap identification, his post-snap processing is limited and often predetermined. He tends to lock onto initial reads and struggles when defenses rotate or disguise coverage. The speed and complexity of NFL defenses are likely to overwhelm him early, requiring a simplified system to function efficiently.
ARM TALENT
Simpson has adequate arm strength but lacks consistent touch and trajectory control. He often fires passes on a rope, resulting in flat throws with little arc and a narrow margin for error. This approach leads to occasional ugly misses, particularly on intermediate and layered routes. His mechanics suggest he puts noticeable effort into generating velocity, which limits consistency and makes his ball placement unreliable at times.
RUSHING/MOBILITY
Simpson provides minimal value as a runner. He is capable of taking straightforward, uncovered rushing lanes but lacks the athleticism to create outside of structure. While he can escape the pocket to buy additional time, he is not a dynamic threat on the move. His mobility is functional rather than advantageous and does not meaningfully raise his offensive or fantasy ceiling.
MANAGEMENT
Turnovers are a notable concern. Simpson has put the ball in harm’s way with loose pocket security and several costly interceptions. While he generally avoids forcing throws and is willing to take what the defense gives him, his mistakes tend to be severe and momentum-shifting. Cleaning up ball security and decision-making under pressure will be essential if he is to earn NFL trust.
FANTASY OUTLOOK
Simpson offers very little appeal from a fantasy standpoint. He lacks rushing upside and profiles as a one-read quarterback who relies heavily on structure and support. While he can deliver an occasional impressive throw, his overall ceiling is limited. In rookie drafts, he should not command more than a late-to-mid second-round pick and is best viewed as depth rather than a building block.
SUBTLE ARTS
Mechanically, Simpson is sound, but his long release impacts timing and anticipation, particularly on rhythm throws. This delay can allow defenders to close windows more quickly than anticipated. One of his strongest traits is pocket navigation, especially within the interior. He shows the ability to subtly climb or slide to buy an extra beat, which helps compensate for his limited creativity elsewhere.
IDEAL TEAM FITS
Simpson needs an environment with quick-separating receivers and strong offensive line play to mitigate his processing and mobility limitations. He is best suited to develop as a backup behind an established veteran rather than being thrust into early action. Logical schematic fits include the Detroit Lions, Los Angeles Rams, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
SCOUTPOTATO
Scouting Academy (Coming Soon)